Blab Entertainment
Star Wars Jedi Order: Origins, Temples, and Ethical Questions Revealed by New Canon
Star Wars’ Jedi Order has long been a central element of the franchise, yet recent canon releases have highlighted several inconsistencies that puzzle fans and scholars alike. A 2024 article on ComicBook.com outlines five key questions that remain unresolved, from the order’s earliest beginnings to the ethical use of the Jedi Mind Trick.
The first question concerns the Jedi’s origin. According to the ComicBook.com piece, the Jedi evolved from an earlier Force cult known as the Bendu. The Bendu were an ancient group that lived near Coruscant, and the name “Bendu” appears in the canon as a day of the week on Coruscant. The article notes that this connection is a nod to George Lucas’s original plan for the Jedi, which he referred to as the “Jedi Bendu” or “Dai Bendu.”
The second inconsistency arises from the location of the first Jedi Temple. The 2017 film Star Wars: The Last Jedi reveals the temple on the distant planet Ahch‑To, a world in the Unknown Regions far from the Galactic Core. The temple’s existence on Ahch‑To is documented in the Star Wars Databank and in the Star Wars Wookieepedia entry for the Ahch‑To Jedi Temple, which states that the temple was established around 25,025 BBY. The article points out that this placement conflicts with the Bendu origin, which would suggest a more central location.
A third option emerges from the live‑action series Ahsoka. In the first season, the character Baylan Skoll mentions the extragalactic planet Peridea, where a war between light and dark supposedly began. Peridea is described in the Star Wars Wookieepedia entry as a planet located in a distant galaxy, far from the one where the New Republic operates. The series hints that the first Jedi may have risen against an intergalactic empire that used hyperspace‑traveling Purrgil to cross the void between galaxies. The article notes that this narrative adds a third layer to the Jedi’s origins, making it difficult to reconcile with the Bendu and Ahch‑To stories.
The fourth question deals with the Jedi Mind Trick. The article explains that the Mind Trick was the first Force power shown in the franchise, but it is also the most ethically ambiguous. The Jedi Code discourages the use of the Force to manipulate others, yet the Mind Trick is frequently employed in the films and television series. The article cites the Star Wars High Republic era, where the use of the Mind Trick was controversial and looked upon with suspicion. It also references the Star Wars canon where Kylo Ren uses a Mind Trick to probe a Sith mind, illustrating how the power can be weaponized.
The fifth and final question concerns the Chosen One prophecy. The article notes that the prophecy, as explained in Claudia Gray’s 2019 novel Master & Apprentice, states that a Chosen One will be born of no father and will restore ultimate balance in the Force. The prophecy’s meaning is unclear, especially since the Jedi traditionally emphasize the light side of the Force. The article points out that Qui‑Gon Jinn believed the Chosen One had to become a Jedi, a belief that Lucas later said was incorrect.
The article concludes by examining why the Jedi ignored Anakin Skywalker’s red flags. It notes that Yoda recognized Anakin’s potential for darkness early in the Clone Wars, yet the Jedi Council did not intervene. The article cites the Star Wars High Republic series, where Yoda’s approach to Anakin is explored, and it suggests that the Jedi’s failure to address Anakin’s attachment and aggression contributed to the Order’s downfall.
In sum, the latest canon releases have added layers to the Jedi Order’s history, but they have also introduced new contradictions. The Bendu origin, the Ahch‑To temple, and the Peridea revelation each offer distinct timelines that are difficult to reconcile. The ethical debate over the Mind Trick and the unresolved nature of the Chosen One prophecy further complicate the narrative. As new Star Wars projects continue to release, the franchise may eventually provide a more cohesive explanation, but for now, the inconsistencies remain.
The first question concerns the Jedi’s origin. According to the ComicBook.com piece, the Jedi evolved from an earlier Force cult known as the Bendu. The Bendu were an ancient group that lived near Coruscant, and the name “Bendu” appears in the canon as a day of the week on Coruscant. The article notes that this connection is a nod to George Lucas’s original plan for the Jedi, which he referred to as the “Jedi Bendu” or “Dai Bendu.”
The second inconsistency arises from the location of the first Jedi Temple. The 2017 film Star Wars: The Last Jedi reveals the temple on the distant planet Ahch‑To, a world in the Unknown Regions far from the Galactic Core. The temple’s existence on Ahch‑To is documented in the Star Wars Databank and in the Star Wars Wookieepedia entry for the Ahch‑To Jedi Temple, which states that the temple was established around 25,025 BBY. The article points out that this placement conflicts with the Bendu origin, which would suggest a more central location.
A third option emerges from the live‑action series Ahsoka. In the first season, the character Baylan Skoll mentions the extragalactic planet Peridea, where a war between light and dark supposedly began. Peridea is described in the Star Wars Wookieepedia entry as a planet located in a distant galaxy, far from the one where the New Republic operates. The series hints that the first Jedi may have risen against an intergalactic empire that used hyperspace‑traveling Purrgil to cross the void between galaxies. The article notes that this narrative adds a third layer to the Jedi’s origins, making it difficult to reconcile with the Bendu and Ahch‑To stories.
The fourth question deals with the Jedi Mind Trick. The article explains that the Mind Trick was the first Force power shown in the franchise, but it is also the most ethically ambiguous. The Jedi Code discourages the use of the Force to manipulate others, yet the Mind Trick is frequently employed in the films and television series. The article cites the Star Wars High Republic era, where the use of the Mind Trick was controversial and looked upon with suspicion. It also references the Star Wars canon where Kylo Ren uses a Mind Trick to probe a Sith mind, illustrating how the power can be weaponized.
The fifth and final question concerns the Chosen One prophecy. The article notes that the prophecy, as explained in Claudia Gray’s 2019 novel Master & Apprentice, states that a Chosen One will be born of no father and will restore ultimate balance in the Force. The prophecy’s meaning is unclear, especially since the Jedi traditionally emphasize the light side of the Force. The article points out that Qui‑Gon Jinn believed the Chosen One had to become a Jedi, a belief that Lucas later said was incorrect.
The article concludes by examining why the Jedi ignored Anakin Skywalker’s red flags. It notes that Yoda recognized Anakin’s potential for darkness early in the Clone Wars, yet the Jedi Council did not intervene. The article cites the Star Wars High Republic series, where Yoda’s approach to Anakin is explored, and it suggests that the Jedi’s failure to address Anakin’s attachment and aggression contributed to the Order’s downfall.
In sum, the latest canon releases have added layers to the Jedi Order’s history, but they have also introduced new contradictions. The Bendu origin, the Ahch‑To temple, and the Peridea revelation each offer distinct timelines that are difficult to reconcile. The ethical debate over the Mind Trick and the unresolved nature of the Chosen One prophecy further complicate the narrative. As new Star Wars projects continue to release, the franchise may eventually provide a more cohesive explanation, but for now, the inconsistencies remain.
